Grievous could still do all those things, we just never saw him face those Jedi Masters in the Clone Wars. In their first encounter, he got the jump and them and pulled out all of his stunts he could. The Jedi weren't prepared. He was a constant challenge for Obi-Wan, one of the most powerful Jedi aside from Mace and Yoda. Kit Fisto had to retreat from his battle with Grievous, and the only real times Grevious was defeated was through sheer arrogance and luck, which fits his character. Hell, he killed Mother Talzin.

If he could still do all those things, then when did he ever do them? All I remember from TCW fights with him was that they were terribly dull and slow in comparison. If I'm wrong, I'd love to see a video showing him being deadly and competent like he was.

They didn't? Karen Travis stopped writing because she got butthurt over what a small section of Mandalore looked like. They even acknowledge the existence of Delta Squad in TCW. The Republic Commando game is canon to an extent.

At the time I recall it being said that's what all of Mandalore was like, and that the events weren't limited to that one city/region. That, and Delta Squad's appearance, were damage control from the upset that ensued.

Which Kit Fisto episode? There's a couple spread throughout the series. As well, they never tried to replicate the '03 series, so I don't know where you're getting that idea from.

The water one.

The Clone Wars takes place after Anakin gets his scar on his right eye. The event above was way before that. If you want to see that, it's perfectly available to watch in the '03 series.

I've watched it multiple times. The point still remains that Anakin still was questionable in his actions for quite a while after being granted Knighthood, and his relationship with Padme was rather well known. Giving him a padawan would clearly be a poor choice.

Durge died in the '03 series. He was alive in the comics, which were said to be non canon by Lucas before The Clone Wars came out.

He didn't die though, it was more than evident that he could've lived, and was shown later on, like you said. Saying "he died in the '03 series" is really moot, when Darth Maul died in Episode I, but through far more absurd explanations he was able to come back. They didn't bring him back because they would've been afraid about scaring kids, clearly.

How is portraying a group of old fashion Mandalorians as terrorists who attack innocent citizens make them look "good". Just because you yourself might be rooting for them doesn't make them the story's protagonist.

Mandalorians are a warrior-culture, and when some people are claiming to be Mandalorians, but are pacifists, and the only Mandalorians that are acting the part are a group of terrorists that want to conquer the galaxy, there's a fucking problem. Especially since Mandalorians aren't a race or specific species, being Mandalorian is an idea, you can't accurately claim to be a follower of that idea and not act the part.

The fans have been wanting that since TPM. It added a giant story element and character for Obi-wan as well. You've complained in other posts they don't service the fans, then when they do you complain? It sounds like you're butthurt over them not bending over backwards to service what you want. Guess what? You're not a special snowflake.

What fans, kids? I admit, when I was younger bringing back dead characters to have them fight new and create changes to the story and for other characters seemed like a fantastic and fun idea. However, I would expect more from the official writers than something from the mind of a young boy playing with his action figures. In story, death is supposed to mean something, you just don't bring dead characters back to life because they were cool. Yes, they might've been a great character, but bringing the dead back relentlessly shows disrespect for the character and original story that character played in. This is why in Halo people have been bitching that Cortana shouldn't come back, because the death meant something and voiding it makes that story pointless. Was a reaction elicited from Obi Wan? Yes, but it's nothing we haven't seen before. 

It's far better to create a good new character, than to keep bringing back the dead ones because you liked them and/or you're afraid to pull off something new.

Quote from: Tackelberry on November 30, 2014, 12:27:18 PM

Quote from: The First Noelle on November 30, 2014, 12:25:48 PM

Quote from: aMetroid on November 30, 2014, 12:17:44 PM

It's not up to the audience to decide what is canon and what isn't. If that were the case I'd consider the Metroid Prime series canon.

Of course it is not, but Disney cannot erase thirty years of established canon.

They didn't, it's still there and put into a "Legends" category. They can use anything from it any time they want.

TCW, Rebels, and future movies go into that "Legends" category, because it is an alternate timeline, because it would contradict the EU stuff. Just like how the new Star Trek movies are on a separate timeline.

Are you always this autistic?

Quote from: aMetroid on November 30, 2014, 12:17:44 PM

It's not up to the audience to decide what is canon and what isn't. If that were the case I'd consider the Metroid Prime series canon.

Of course it is not, but Disney cannot erase thirty years of established canon.

Hey Noelle guess what

Nope, those things are not part of the EU.

They may not have been part of the EU originally but now they would be in the same boat. Since the handlers of Star Wars erased the majority of the things outside the movies something like Lego Star Wars would be as canon as what KoTOR is.

and other games like TFU are non-canon.

Except it was before the Disney thing. Since you're saying that game isn't canon than you're saying KoTOR, the Jedi games or anything else isn't as well before Disney.

Fan-fictions are obviously not canon.

Obviously the majority of the EU is as well since Disney which controls Star Wars stated that the majority if the EU isn't canon. Something like KoTOR or the Darth Bane books would be on the same level as a fan fiction story since they're not considered canon.

>being this much of an asshole to Noelle over Star Wars canon.

God, if that is what she wants to believe, it's not hurting anyone. Jesus Christ, this thread is ridiculous. I do accept that they destroyed the EU, but I can see why people would disregard what Disney did. But, you guys should also remember, IT'S ONLY FUCKING STAR WARS. There is no reason for this.

The fuck is EU