New Design Feedback

 
Cheat
| Flora Colossus
 
more |
XBL: Cheatlancer
PSN:
Steam: Cheatlancer
ID: Cheatlancer
IP: Logged

6,668 posts
Hmm...
Hi everybody! It might be a shock, but Septagon 3.0 is something I'm actually making progress on after like 4 years. So, I posted these comps in the Discord channel for development, but I know a lot of you guys don't really participate in it (understandable), so I wanted to make a thread here to get some extra feedback.

The original concept was this:
Spoiler

Nuka pointed out it looks a LOT like B.next. And it does. I kind of naturally...fell into that trend as I designed it so that the focus could be on content, but I do understand the draw to the old way of doing things. After some discussion, I think the best thing to do would be to have the above as the default style for new users and guests, and then have a simple toggle in settings that will let you theme the site with the older style in mind.

Here's what that might look like:
Spoiler

New ranking changes are as follows:
  • On the new style, only staff and special ranks are given colored labels. Normal ranks would look the same but would read differently. The highest rank, Mythic or Marty, would get to be a colored label, to show off.
  • Users would get both a cumulative rank (level) based on posts, activity, liked posts, ban count, etc. over time. This would only go up. Users would also be ranked relatively against each other for their Heroic, Legendary, Mythic, etc.
  • If you use the old style, the nameplates would behave similarly to how they do now, with the background color matching your rank (Legendary, Mythic, etc.).


Lemme know your thoughts here. Would the majority of you be OK with the default theme being the new style as long as you could toggle on the old style from settings? Coup would be an additional option on top of this, so you could have both enabled.

Higher quality videos of these comps are in the discord server.


V | Mythic Inconceivable!
 
more |
XBL: Vien Quitonm
PSN:
Steam: Vien 'Quitonm
ID: Vien
IP: Logged

13,128 posts
Just message me.
vienquitonm is my discord
Will there be beta tests?


 
Cheat
| Flora Colossus
 
more |
XBL: Cheatlancer
PSN:
Steam: Cheatlancer
ID: Cheatlancer
IP: Logged

6,668 posts
Hmm...
Will there be beta tests?
For sure. And alphas before that.


 
Cheat
| Flora Colossus
 
more |
XBL: Cheatlancer
PSN:
Steam: Cheatlancer
ID: Cheatlancer
IP: Logged

6,668 posts
Hmm...
One thing I haven't brought up, you seem to be putting most of your focus on mobile so far. How are things looking for desktop?
Haven't even touched it yet tbh. I'm of the philosophy of progressive enhancement, so as soon as I get a few more mobile screens finished and have a general "feel" of the UI, I'll slug through desktop.

I'm open to ideas if you have some suggestions ahead of time. I know one of the criticisms is that the forum has a lot of wasted space on the side, which is something I do want to address. The other major thing is if we'll have a sidebar in forum view. If so, what will it be?