8>7>3>6>1>4>2>5

i don't expect this one to top TLJ, but i think the disney trilogy has solidified itself as the best

I saw a triple billing of the sequel trilogy last night with the midnight premiere of TROS.

Uhm.

I have no idea what the fuck I watched but I was both horrified by and loving every second of it.

I'm not sure how I could describe it in terms of quality. TLJ is still definitely the best of the trilogy (and the saga), but I think I would rather watch  9 than 7, although I think 7 is the better movie... maybe? I'm still trying to process everything.

4 = 5 = 8 > 7 > Solo > 6 > 3 > 2 > 1 > RO
I'd put 9 either above or below 7

All the leaks from over a month ago turned out to be true. I did not care for this movie and judging by the current reviews, I’m not alone in this sentiment.

Not to be 'that guy' but the more time goes on the more this franchise starts to get horrifically overrated for me.

I'm not just including the sequel and prequel trilogy in that category. Even rewatching the originals I can't help but feel that there's nothing much going on. Not just thematically, but in terms of entertainment value as well. Sometimes I can get through about 30 minutes of ANH and even Empire before my attention starts waning. I actually think Return is probably the best in the whole saga notwithstanding the dreadful Ewok scenes. Lukes confrontation with Vader and Palpatine alone totally compensates for what's kind of a generic space opera franchise.

Credit where credits due though, it was a cool concept that invigorated a genre of odyssey sci fi in the late 70s but it really hasn't aged all that well IMO.

Haven't seen ROS yet but I've read the plot spoilers it and it sounds really half baked.

So here's my ranking until I see it I suppose:

Return > Empire > Revenge (not because its a good film but the memery we got from it lands it a spot here) > ANH > Force Awakens > Phantom > Rogue One > Clones > subatomic dog shit > TLJ

Still haven't seen Solo.

I've only watched it once so far last night, and I was beyond hyped so my thoughts might change with another go. I thought it was good, definitely not as disappointing as I'm seeing people on the internet so far say. There was a lot I wanted to see more of, and them expand but it's a lot to fit into a 2 hour movie. The ending was a little lack luster for a final boss and
I think it'd all been better if TLJ was directed by JJ, and some of this movie could have been done during that. I felt like JJ corrected a lot of the wrongs in my book from TLJ and kinda made it a movie you really dont need to see for the trilogy.

TLJ is the only good star wars movie

*laughs in gungan*

gotta say i'm not looking forward to another year or two of star wars fans being melodramatic just because a film they didn't like came out

star wars is ruined, just like it was in 2017, 2015, 2005, 2002, 1999, 1983, and 1980

it's just a bit tiresome

I think this film has some absolutely horrendous plot points though, some of which actually sabotage the PT/OT's story.

i just rewatched TLJ just to refresh myself, and yeah

anyone who dislikes this movie has absolutely no fucking idea what's good for the franchise

if star wars fans are pissed about it, that's how you know FOR SURE that it's good--that's the litmus test, i guess

looks like i'll be enjoying episode 9

Stupid fucking monkeys at my theater never shut . One bitch two toes ahead of me was playing fucking CoD mobile throughout the movie

Movie itself was messy but I loved it.

Here's a plothole that literally nobody on Earth should care about, but will of course be blown out of proportion by neckbeards

Spoiler

Weren’t Kyber Crystals mined on that one desert planet in Rogue One? IIRC that was a semi-important plot point since those powered the Death Star.

Quote from: CMD.exe on December 20, 2019, 07:55:36 PM

Here's a plothole that literally nobody on Earth should care about, but will of course be blown out of proportion by neckbeards

Spoiler

Starkiller base was actually Illum, where  all Lightsaber kyber crystals come from. So where did Rey get hers? Are we bringing synthetic crystals back into canon

Back on the topic of the movie itself

star wars has always been shit

Quote from: CMD.exe on December 20, 2019, 08:59:10 PM

Quote from: Fedorekd on December 20, 2019, 05:26:20 PM

Clone Wars still remains the absolute peak of star wars content though

Fixed

it was shit

Clone Wars as in the Cartoon, not Attack of the Clones