It's kinda interesting watching news. Left-wing media are panicking and taking it very seriously but right-wing media says it's just another flu.
my state is in lockdown as well
I'm surprised the country isn't on a federal lockdown tbh, if that's even possible. Don't really know the ins and outs of US government emergency responses to a crisis like this, but you think it would have happened by now. You're the third most affected country in the world. New York state alone has higher cases than the entirety of the UK.Then again, Trump.
The responsibility falls to state governments. Just because New York has numerous cases doesn't mean South Dakota needs to take the same measures New York is. What good would federal meddling do? It would just cause more problems in South Dakota, and I'm speaking as somebody that lives in a big state. I've been saying this for years now: the US federal government is an incompetent bureaucratic mess and people need to stop trying to get things done on a federal level. Quote from: Mordo on March 23, 2020, 04:31:36 PMI'm surprised the country isn't on a federal lockdown tbh, if that's even possible. Don't really know the ins and outs of US government emergency responses to a crisis like this, but you think it would have happened by now. You're the third most affected country in the world. New York state alone has higher cases than the entirety of the UK.Then again, Trump.
What's the point in being a unified country
ian's political compass in one sentence
What's the point in being a unified country then? What's the point in even having a federal government if not for enacting emergency powers for this very reason? The "my area isn't affected yet so we don't need to do anything" mentality needs to stop. It's that very mindset which has gotten Europe into the mess it's in right now. Fuck, morons in the UK were treating it like a holiday weekend yesterday, so now the government has had to step in. The containment phase is past the point of no return now. The sooner countries (and states I guess?) start taking this pandemic more seriously the sooner we can resume our lives.
I'm not saying that the federal level shouldn't exist, or that it shouldn't be in charge of things. What I'm saying is that people will often ignore their state/local governments when those are perfectly reasonable institutions for such situations. I distinctly remember back in 2012/2013 one guy was going state to state trying to abolish the death penalty via their state governments, made significantly more progress than any federal push on the issue. I live in Florida where we're known for being slapped in the face by hurricanes non-stop, but all those strict building codes, reconstruction, and other forms of aid came from state of Florida, very little actually gets to us in the form of federal assistance. Also I find it ironic making such a statement on being unified yet Italy and most other European countries are struggling with the virus themselves despite the EU being a thing. Quote from: Mordo on March 23, 2020, 08:02:34 PMWhat's the point in being a unified country then? What's the point in even having a federal government if not for enacting emergency powers for this very reason? The "my area isn't affected yet so we don't need to do anything" mentality needs to stop. It's that very mindset which has gotten Europe into the mess it's in right now. Fuck, morons in the UK were treating it like a holiday weekend yesterday, so now the government has had to step in. The containment phase is past the point of no return now. The sooner countries (and states I guess?) start taking this pandemic more seriously the sooner we can resume our lives.
Using hurricanes as a comparison isn't exactly the best example for a contagious virus that isn't restricted by geography or climate. Bit weird that this contagion is literally on the verge of ripping the arse out of your country and what's concerning you the most is the 'gubberment'.
You brought up emergencies; and my issue isn't the government, it's people not relying on their local/state government. Quote from: Mordo on March 23, 2020, 08:36:19 PMUsing hurricanes as a comparison isn't exactly the best example for a contagious virus that isn't restricted by geography or climate. Bit weird that this contagion is literally on the verge of ripping the arse out of your country and what's concerning you the most is the 'gubberment'.
It's an international crisis affecting multiple countries and unions my man. Italy is reporting 500 plus deaths a day. Spain isn't far behind. Given the current trajectory the US is on you guys look to be giving them a run for their money in the coming days. If that doesn't warrant federal/national government intervention instead of state intervention then I'm not sure what does.
I mean, there are measures by the national government, but things like enforcing a lock down or keeping people at home would be difficult for the national government to do. Quote from: Mordo on March 23, 2020, 08:51:51 PMIt's an international crisis affecting multiple countries and unions my man. Italy is reporting 500 plus deaths a day. Spain isn't far behind. Given the current trajectory the US is on you guys look to be giving them a run for their money in the coming days. If that doesn't warrant federal/national government intervention instead of state intervention then I'm not sure what does.
>biggest, most advanced military in the world>modernised police force>difficult to lockdownSometimes I think Americans know less about their society than the rest of the world does.
Police force is operated by city and state governments. And the governor of the state deploys the national guard IIRC. Quote from: Mordo on March 23, 2020, 09:21:32 PM>biggest, most advanced military in the world>modernised police force>difficult to lockdownSometimes I think Americans know less about their society than the rest of the world does.
Quote from: Ian on March 23, 2020, 09:49:47 PMPolice force is operated by city and state governments. And the governor of the state deploys the national guard IIRC. Quote from: Mordo on March 23, 2020, 09:21:32 PM>biggest, most advanced military in the world>modernised police force>difficult to lockdownSometimes I think Americans know less about their society than the rest of the world does. And federal government can overrule the state in a time of crisis no?
how are libertarians coping with the fact that coronavirus has annihilated their entire ideology
And federal government can overrule the state in a time of crisis no?
Theoretically yes, but what difference does it make with the Fed controlling the police force and national guard when the jobs of both are still "Roam the streets and enforce curfews on non-essential workers"? Quote from: Mordo on March 24, 2020, 05:08:04 AMAnd federal government can overrule the state in a time of crisis no?
Are you seriously trying to argue that the massively funded federal government which is designed to respond to situations like this, with specialised forces and scientists at their disposal, is at all comparable to a state trooper whose 9 to 5 job it is to patrol the highway?
I don't understand where this is coming from. You just asked if the Federal government could overrule the state government and take control of the situation, which they can. But what would the federal government do in that situation that they haven't done already and can't already be handled by the state/city government? Quote from: Mordo on March 24, 2020, 09:47:01 AMAre you seriously trying to argue that the massively funded federal government which is designed to respond to situations like this, with specialised forces and scientists at their disposal, is at all comparable to a state trooper whose 9 to 5 job it is to patrol the highway?
I swear, you yanks would have literal walkers roaming the streets and you'd still be like "I am a PROUD Trump supporter and I will gladly DIE on the job at Foot Locker if it means the federal government stays out of our lives!"Federal government = more resources and better equipment to deal with national crises. State government pertains to LOCALISED issues, which is clearly not what you are dealing with here. I'm not even American and even I can grasp that basic concept. Why is this so difficult for you.