I bought it when it came out last year (TLOU:R, not the original obviously) and it seemed good but ehh screamy corridors full of jumpscare rape-machines was not my idea of fun. So it sat on the shelf for about 9 months and then the other week (3 or so ago) I picked up where I'd left off and just laughed my way through shoulderbitingsimulator2014 (The difference wearing headphones makes eh?) and got through the worst of the jumpscare rape-machines to the point where you are killing meatbags primarily which is a much more enjoyable experience and by that time you have enough weapons to comfortably take out any Ainsley Harriotts that come after you.

I haven't finished the story yet but I know the plot vaguely well enough to tell that I'm close to the end. The story is done pretty well, above average for video game plotlines and if you contrast it with destiny it's shakespeare incarnate but  yeah, the story might be a bit of a generic zombie apocalypse sort of deal but it's done well enough to have you wanting to play the next part rather than just 'Is this over yet?' like some games tend to do.

The CQB kills are deliciously brutal, ramming faces into the edges of walls and all sorts of creative shit. Gunplay is alright, usually comes down to OHK with the 9mm pistol for all meatbag enemies though so it's not really challenging.

I'd say 'predictable' kind of covers the story so far, or the major 'plot-twists' which mostly involve a 'oh this is going to happen' -> It happens.

All in all I'd say it's a fun game/worth buying but it's not quite the HYPEHYPEHYPEGOTYGOTYGOTY chimpout that went on around it's release.

tl;dr you should enjoy it